Between the Lines: October 31, 2025 NHL Betting Picks & Projections | Halloween Edition
- Jason Moser
- Oct 31
- 6 min read
Defensive Demons Dominate Trick-or-Treat Night
Happy Halloween. While trick-or-treaters hunt candy, we're hunting value in tonight's spooky three-game slate. Colorado visits Vegas for a Nevada Day matinee at 4:00 PM ET, the Islanders visit Washington on NHL Network at 7:00 PM, and John Gibson returns to haunt his former team in Anaheim at 10:00 PM.
Our Monte Carlo simulation engine has processed all three matchups with 10,000 iterations each, and the numbers reveal something genuinely frightening: UNDER totals dominate tonight's value landscape. Books have set totals at 6.5 across the board, but our simulations project scoring environments averaging just 5.0 goals per game.
Halloween should bring defensive hockey. Smart money recognizes that elite goaltending present exploitable opportunities.
Feature Game: Colorado Avalanche at Vegas Golden Knights (4:00 PM ET)
Projection: COL 3.29 | VGK 3.05 | Total 6.34
Vegas Total: 6.5
Confidence: Medium
Jack Eichel needs one point to hit 20 and become the fastest Vegas player to reach that milestone. The NHL's leading scorer (19 points in 10 games) headlines this Nevada Day matinee, but our simulation projects 5.47 total goals, which is over a full goal below the 6.5 market number. The UNDER hits in 67.2% of outcomes, yet -120 odds imply just 54.5% probability. That 12.7-percentage-point raw edge produces a solid bet opportunity.
The Betting Lens:
Both teams have just one regulation loss this season (COL 6-1-4, VGK 6-1-3). Mackenzie Blackwood could get his first start of the season, while Vegas likely counters with Akira Schmid. Nathan MacKinnon (9 goals, tied for NHL lead) faces a Vegas defense that has been pretty tight.
The 4:00 PM ET timing historically suppresses scoring as teams establish structure before opening up offensively. Neither enters on a back-to-back, but the afternoon scheduling combined with the magnitude (statement game between West's elite) suggests coaches will prioritize structure.
Vegas +1.5 at -250 covers in 82.3% of simulations as a secondary play, carrying a 7.84% Modified Kelly edge despite the heavy juice.
The Storyline Worth Watching:
Beyond Eichel's 20-point chase, this features the only two NHL teams with one regulation loss. If the first period stays 0-0 or 1-0, the UNDER becomes increasingly likely as both teams recognize the defensive chess match.
Want to see where our model finds the strongest edges on Halloween night? 👇
Enjoy a 7-day FREE TRIAL to PuckLuck+ starting today for all NHL betting picks and analysis
