Unlocking Canada's Defensive Depth: The Top 5 Options to Keep on the Radar to Replace Shea Theodore in Case of Another Injury
- Jason Moser
- Feb 13
- 4 min read
In the fast-paced world of best-on-best hockey, injuries can change everything. They can shake a team’s confidence and disrupt its rhythm, especially during crucial tournaments like the 4 Nations Face-Off. Team Canada is first to face this challenge—specifically, in maintaining a strong defensive lineup.
With star defenseman Shea Theodore sidelined due to injury, finding a competent replacement is essential. Canada will not be able to add to the roster unless another defenseman goes down, with Travis Sanheim available to step in immediately.
Let's explore five players who might be perfect candidates to keep on stand-by: Evan Bouchard, Dougie Hamilton, Thomas Chabot, Mackenzie Weegar, and Bowen Byram. Each of these players has something unique to offer, making the depth of Canada’s talent pool quite impressive.
Canada's Need for a Shea Theodore Replacement
Shea Theodore is not just another defenseman. He plays a vital role for Team Canada, known for his excellent speed, puck control, and power play prowess. When a player like Theodore is out, it creates a significant void that a strong replacement needs to fill. This situation highlights the importance of consistently evaluating potential candidates to ensure the team's continued success.
Identifying the skills and strengths of each player can guide Canada in making the best decision. Below, we take a closer look at five options to keep on the radar to strengthen Canada’s defensive lineup.
Evan Bouchard: The Rising Star
Evan Bouchard is making a name for himself with the Edmonton Oilers. His combination of offensive talent and solid defensive skills makes him a noteworthy candidate.
While Bouchard might not replicate Theodore’s style perfectly, he brings youth and eagerness to excel at the highest level. His booming right-handed shot is an asset, creating scoring chances from the point. In the 2023-2024 NHL season, he recorded 82 points in 81 games, showcasing his scoring potential.
Although he is still sharpening his defensive game, Bouchard's offensive intelligence and power play success makes him a viable choice, especially when injuries disrupt the team.
Dougie Hamilton: The Seasoned Veteran
Dougie Hamilton is a seasoned NHL veteran who brings significant experience and offense to any team. Although he's a right-handed shot, Hamilton can replace a lot of Shea Theodore's attributes directly.
What sets Hamilton apart is his versatility. He can handle heavy minutes, lead the power play, and effectively contribute to penalty kills. His track record in high-pressure situations is essential for Team Canada, particularly in tournaments where every match is crucial.
Hamilton hasn't participated for Team Canada in over 10 years, but his deep playoff runs with the New Jersey Devils, Carolina Hurricanes, and Boston Bruins underline his capability to perform when it matters most.
Thomas Chabot: The Direct Replacement
Thomas Chabot is a standout option for stepping directly into Theodore's shoes. As a member of the Ottawa Senators, Chabot combines the speed, skill, and playmaking that most closely mirrors Theodore's style of play.
Chabot excels at moving the puck and is known for creating plays. His offensive contributions have been impressive, with an average of a 48 point-pace per season over his NHL career. This offensive capability, along with his ability to skate well and integrate into Team Canada’s fast-paced play, makes him an ideal replacement.
Chabot is well-prepared to handle the demands of international competition, starring for Team Canada in two World Junior Championships and participating in three World Championships since.
Mackenzie Weegar: The Multidimensional Player
Mackenzie Weegar has established himself as a key player for the Calgary Flames. With strong defensive skills and a physical approach, Weegar could fill in effectively for Theodore and bring a different element to the team.
He is known for excelling in defensive situations, such as one-on-one matchups. His versatility allows him to play on either side of the ice, making him adaptable for Team Canada. So far during the 2024-2025 season, he has averaged a career-high 23:38 of ice time per game, showing his capability to handle pressure and play in all situations.
While Weegar may not score as frequently as Theodore, his excellent positioning and shot-blocking are invaluable traits for any team facing critical moments in games.
Bowen Byram: The Future Star
Bowen Byram, currently with the Buffalo Sabres, stands out as a young talent on the rise. With remarkable agility and a focus on puck transition, Byram represents the future of Canadian defense.
Byram's ability to escape danger and join offensive rushes is impressive. He's come on strong this season, posting 29 points in 54 games while becoming a staple on the Sabres' top pair with Rasmus Dahlin. His quick decision-making on the ice mirrors the smart plays fans appreciate in Theodore.
Despite more limited experience, Byram's upside and growth this season make him a compelling option for Team Canada when a skilled replacement is needed.
Canada's Defensive Depth
Should Team Canada need someone to step up in Shea Theodore's absence, they have several capable options to consider. From Evan Bouchard's youthful offensive flair to Thomas Chabot’s seamless fit as a direct replacement, the talent pool remains robust.
Dougie Hamilton’s valuable experience and Mackenzie Weegar’s multi-faceted play make them strong contenders. Bowen Byram's growth and promise signal a bright future for the Canadian defense.
These candidates share a common thread: they're all capable of stepping in and contributing right away. As the 4 Nations tournament unfolds, it will be intriguing to see who emerges to fill the defensive void. If eventually faced with an emergency choice, Team Canada’s depth can further shine, keeping them firmly as contenders on the international stage.
Comments