Between the Lines: October 18, 2025 NHL Betting Picks & Projections

Saturday evening's 10-game finish features Jack Eichel's league-leading scoring tear and altitude advantage in Denver.

Saturday's action continues with 10 games spanning prime time through late-night Pacific finishes. Our model has identified significant betting edges across multiple evening matchups, including a stunning 22.5% edge on a road underdog and double-digit total opportunities where the books appear to have mispriced offensive potential. With Jack Eichel torching the league with 11 points in five games and Colorado's altitude advantage creating scoring opportunities, sharp value dominates tonight's remaining slate.

Tonight's Action: 10-Game Evening Slate

Prime Time (7:00 PM ET):

• TBL @ CBJ - Lightning visit Blue Jackets

• NYR @ MTL - Rangers face Canadiens at Bell Centre

• MIN @ PHI - Wild travel to Philadelphia

• DAL @ STL - Stars visit Blues

• SEA @ TOR (NHLN) - Kraken at Maple Leafs on national TV

• NSH @ WPG - Predators visit Jets

Mountain/Pacific Window:

• 9:00 PM ET: BOS @ COL, CAR @ LAK - Altitude advantage meets West Coast hockey

• 10:00 PM ET: PIT @ SJ, CGY @ VGK - Late-night finishes with Eichel's scoring showcase

Key Factors:

• Jack Eichel leads NHL with 11 points (5G, 6A) through five games for Vegas

• Calgary hits T-Mobile Arena as massive underdogs despite model showing 53% edge

• Boston travels to Denver where altitude historically boosts scoring totals

• Seattle visits Toronto on NHLN in evening's only nationally televised matchup

• Multiple late-night opportunities on West Coast with exploitable edges

Game of the Night: SEATTLE @ TORONTO (NHLN)

The Setup:

The only nationally televised game on Saturday night brings the Kraken into Scotiabank Arena to face a Maple Leafs squad looking to establish consistency early in the season. Toronto enters as solid home favorites at -230, but NHLN viewers get a showcase of contrasting styles as Seattle's defensive structure meets Toronto's offensive firepower. Our model projects this as closer than the market suggests, though the Leafs remain rightful favorites.

PuckLuck Projection:

SEA: 2.48 goals | TOR: 3.52 goals

Projected Total: 6.00

The books have Toronto as heavy favorites at -230, implying a 69.7% win probability. Our model projects 69.4%, which is essentially aligned, offering no significant moneyline edge. Seattle at +185 carries implied probability of 35.1% versus our 30.6% projection, meaning the market slightly overvalues the Kraken's road upset chances.

The Storyline:

This matchup features two teams still finding their identity through the season's first weeks. Toronto boasts offensive weapons throughout the lineup, while Seattle relies on structured defense and timely goaltending to stay competitive. The Maple Leafs' home ice advantage at Scotiabank Arena creates energy, but the Kraken have shown they can frustrate high-powered offenses with disciplined play.

The Total Play:

With our projection of 6.00 goals sitting exactly on the Vegas total of 6.0, there's no mathematical edge on either OVER or UNDER. The game should produce offense from Toronto while Seattle keeps things tight defensively. NHLN viewers can expect competitive hockey, but bettors should look elsewhere for value tonight.

Want to see where our model finds the strongest edges tonight? 👇

Enjoy a 7-day FREE TRIAL to PuckLuck+ starting today (October 16 2025) for all NHL betting picks and analysis

PREMIUM PLAYS (PuckLuck+ Subscribers)

3 High-Confidence Bets + Props Section

NHL Betting Picks for October 18, 2025

1. CALGARY FLAMES ML (+200) @ Vegas

Confidence: MEDIUM

Edge: 22.5%

The Play: Calgary Flames ML at +200

The Storyline:

Jack Eichel enters tonight's matchup as the NHL's leading scorer with 11 points through five games, including four multi-point performances. Vegas signed Eichel to an eight-year, $108M extension during the offseason, and he's rewarding that faith with dominance. The Golden Knights are rolling at home, where T-Mobile Arena provides significant energy. Calgary counters as road underdogs riding a modest start but possessing the talent to keep games competitive.

The Setup:

Our model projects Calgary with a 54.8% win probability. At +200, the implied probability is just 33.3%, which is a staggering 21.5% edge, the largest on tonight's slate. Vegas enters as -250 favorites, but our projections suggest the market has severely overvalued the home team and Eichel's hot streak. The Flames' underlying metrics show competitive possession numbers, and getting them at plus-money creates exceptional value.

The Edge:

This represents the type of mispricing that occurs when public perception (Eichel's scoring, home ice) overwhelms actual win probability. Our model accounts for recent form, goaltending matchups, and roster quality, which all suggest that Calgary offers legitimate upset potential. At +200, a $100 wager returns $200 profit if the Flames win. With a 54.8% projected win probability, the expected value here is massive.

The Reasoning:

Sometimes the market overreacts to narratives. Eichel's scoring streak and Vegas' home ice create a perception that the Golden Knights should be overwhelming favorites. Our model disagrees. Calgary possesses the defensive structure to limit high-danger chances and the offensive firepower to capitalize on mistakes. This is a calculated risk on a road underdog where the numbers tell a different story than the betting line.

2. BOSTON @ COLORADO OVER 5.5 (-110)

Confidence: MEDIUM-HIGH

Edge: 18.55%

The Play: OVER 5.5 goals at -110

The Storyline:

The Bruins travel to Ball Arena, where Colorado's altitude advantage traditionally creates high-scoring affairs. Boston brings one of the league's better scoring lines, while the Avalanche possess game-breaking talent throughout their lineup. Both teams have shown willingness to trade chances, and the thin Denver air historically boosts goal totals. This 9:00 PM ET Mountain Time start gives viewers a showcase of skill versus skill.

The Setup:

Our projection of 6.52 goals sits 1.02 above the Vegas total of 5.5 - that's an 18.55% differential. This represents substantial value on the OVER, especially at -110 where we're getting close to even money on a total our model suggests should be 6.0 or higher. Both teams' recent games have featured offensive production, and neither goaltender profiles as a shutout-level dominator.

The Edge:

Colorado's home ice at altitude creates fatigue and opens up the game late. Boston's defensive metrics show vulnerability in transition, exactly where the Avalanche excel. The pace will be high, both teams push tempo, and special teams should see opportunities. Our model simulates this game hitting 6+ goals approximately 68% of the time, meaning the OVER at 5.5 carries significant mathematical advantage.

The Reasoning:

Altitude games in Denver historically produce offense. Both teams possess elite offensive talent with Boston's balanced attack versus Colorado's star power. With neither defense projecting as dominant and both teams likely to generate power-play opportunities, this game should feature consistent scoring throughout. The 18.55% edge represents one of the cleaner OVER plays on tonight's massive slate.

3. COLUMBUS BLUE JACKETS ML (-120) vs Tampa Bay

Confidence: MEDIUM-HIGH

Edge: 8.7%

The Play: Columbus Blue Jackets ML at -120

The Storyline:

Let's call it like it is - the Tampa Bay Lightning have been BAD this season. Traveling to Columbus after an overtime loss in Detroit last night certainly doesn't help. The uncertainty around star winger Nikita Kucherov - who missed last night's game with an illness - doesn't help their cause either. The Blue Jackets aren't off to a great start either, but possess the young firepower for a potential jolt of offense.

The Setup:

Our Coumbus win probability of 63% sits 8.7% higher than the sportsbook implied odds of 54.3%. We're laying juice, but the moneyline edge justifies the investment. The Blue Jackets are at home, more rested than Tampa, and looking for an early-season statement game.

The Edge:

No Kucherov means expanded offensive role for unproven players like Conor Geekie and Gage Goncalves. Meanwhile, the Blue Jackets will have a PuckLuck model darling Jet Greaves in net. Greaves is already off to a great start this season despite being winless - posting a .932 save percentage in his two starts.

The Reasoning:

When our model projects nearly a 9% discrepancy from the sportsbooks, it warrants attention. The early season volatility can play a role in the model's projections, but the same goes for the sportsbooks' handicapping. If Columbus can establish a lead early, Greaves and company should be able to take this one at home.

PLAYER PROPS TO CONSIDER

Add these October 18, 2025 props to your NHL betting picks card for tonight's action

ANYTIME GOALSCORER: Bryan Rust (+165)

The Case: After hitting on Jeff Skinner at +425 yesterday, we're going more modest with Bryan Rust against Skinner and the Sharks. San Jose is on a back-to-back, and the correlation with Sidney Crosby - on top of their established chemistry - is too good to pass up. Rust is our most likely goalscorer on the evening slate, so this is a high-confidence prop bet.

POINT PROP: Sean Monahan 2+ Points (+320)

The Case: Since we went more conservative on the goal scorer, let's have some fun with Monahan's point prop today. Extend that puppy to 2+, for all of the reasons listed above, and see if the Blue Jackets' top line and/or power play can capitalize on backup Jonas Johansson being in net instead of Andrei Vasilevskiy. Monahan is pointless to start the season, but this feels like a get-right spot.

SHOTS ON GOAL: Pavel Dorofeyev 4+ Shots (+135)

The Case: Dorofeyev is shooting from everywhere this season, and why not when you have 6 goals in 5 games. Linemate Mitch Marner is as good as it gets as a setup man, and the Calgary Flames are top-10 in the league in shots allowed. Key in on Dorofeyev in a potential boom game.

Bottom Line

Tonight's Focus: Exploit market inefficiencies on underdogs and target OVER plays where altitude and pace boost scoring

High Confidence Plays:

1. CGY ML (+200) - 53.06% edge (MEDIUM confidence)

2. BOS/COL OVER 5.5 (-110) - 18.55% edge (MEDIUM-HIGH confidence)

3. CBJ ML (-120) - 8.7% edge (MEDIUM-HIGH confidence)

Top Props:

• Bryan Rust Anytime Goal (+165)

• Sean Monahan 2+ Points (+320)

• Pavel Dorofeyev 4+ SOG (+135)

• 
  

Risk Management:

Massive 13-game slate means concentrated exposure across multiple spots. Recommended allocation: 40% on Calgary ML (highest edge despite moderate confidence), 30% on BOS/COL OVER (altitude advantage plus edge), 20% on CBJ ML, 10% on props. The Calgary play represents exceptional value at +200 where our model sees a near-even matchup severely mispriced by the market.

These are probability-based plays optimizing long-term portfolio growth. The 22.5% edge on Calgary represents the type of market inefficiency we target - where public perception diverges from mathematical reality. The two OVER plays capitalize on pace, altitude, and goaltending matchups that favor scoring.

Live Updates:

Monitor the Calgary line - if it moves below +180, our edge diminishes significantly. The BOS/COL total is relatively stable but watch for any late goaltending changes that could impact the projection. CBJ ML edge remains strong unless the line moves to -140.

Follow @PuckLuckDotCom for real-time alerts on lineup changes or significant line movements.

All projections and edges calculated using PuckLuck's proprietary model based on current roster composition, recent performance, and situational factors. Confidence levels reflect sample size reliability rather than specific percentages. These are probability-based recommendations for portfolio optimization, not guaranteed outcomes. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Please gamble responsibly.